Cause-and-Effect Reasoning on the SAT
How to Trace Why Things Happen in Any Passage
Track the author’s logic, locate evidence quickly, and sharpen your reasoning.
Evidence-First Reading
Anchor every answer in the exact line that proves it. If you cannot point to the words, it is not the answer.
- Read the question, then scan for the line that directly supports a choice.
- Match wording, not vibe: synonyms are fine, new ideas are not.
- If two answers feel close, eliminate the one with any extra claim.
Why Cause-and-Effect Reasoning Matters on the SAT
At its core, every SAT Reading passage tells a story about why things happen. A scientist discovers that a chemical triggers cell growth. A historian argues that economic pressure caused a political revolution. A novelist reveals the hidden reason behind a character's devastating choice. Tracing these cause-and-effect threads is the key to unlocking some of the highest-value questions on the entire test.
Cause-and-effect questions fall under the inference category, which means the answer isn't always spelled out for you in a single sentence. Sometimes you need to connect two pieces of information that the author has placed near each other and reason about why one led to the other. That might sound challenging, but here's the good news: it's a learnable, repeatable skill. Once you know what to look for, these questions become some of the most predictable on the SAT.
If you're already comfortable finding explicit details in a passage, locating a specific fact or statement the author makes directly, then you're ready for this next step. Cause-and-effect reasoning builds on that foundation by asking you to think one level deeper: not just what the passage says, but why it happens.
What Is This Skill?
At its core, cause-and-effect reasoning is the mental operation of linking an outcome (what happened) to a reason (why it happened). When you read a sentence like "The crops failed because of the prolonged drought," you're performing cause-and-effect reasoning almost automatically. The drought is the cause; the crop failure is the effect.
On the SAT, cause-and-effect relationships appear in two forms, and recognizing the difference between them is essential:
Explicit Cause-and-Effect
The author uses signal words that directly announce the relationship. Words and phrases like because, therefore, as a result, consequently, due to, since, led to, and thus are your clearest clues. When you see these, the author is essentially handing you the connection on a silver platter.
Implicit Cause-and-Effect
No signal words appear. Instead, the author places two events or facts near each other and expects you to infer the causal connection from context, logic, and proximity. For example: "The factory shut down in March. By summer, unemployment in the town had doubled." There's no because or therefore, but the causal link is strongly implied. These are the questions that reward careful, active readers.
Common Cause-and-Effect Question Stems
- "Based on the passage, what caused…"
- "According to the text, [event] most likely occurred because…"
- "The author suggests that [outcome] was the result of…"
- "Which choice best explains why [event] happened?"
- "It can reasonably be inferred that [event] led to…"
Just as important as knowing the question patterns is understanding the trap answer types that the SAT uses to pull you off track:
Cause-and-Effect Trap Types
- Reversed Causation: The answer flips cause and effect. If the passage says A caused B, this trap says B caused A. It uses the right vocabulary from the passage but gets the direction of the relationship backward.
- Correlation-as-Causation: Two things are associated in the text, but the answer claims one directly caused the other without sufficient evidence. The passage may only show that they occurred together.
- True-but-Irrelevant: The answer states something accurate from the passage, but it doesn't actually address the causal relationship the question asks about. It's designed to tempt you because it "sounds right."
- Overreach: The answer takes a small, specific cause-and-effect relationship from the passage and stretches it into a sweeping generalization that the author never intended.
A Reliable Strategy for Cause-and-Effect Reasoning
Here's a five-step approach you can use every time you encounter a cause-and-effect question. The more you practice it, the more automatic it becomes.
- Identify the Question Type
Read the question stem and look for causal language, words like because, caused, result of, led to, or why. If you see any of these, you're dealing with a cause-and-effect question.
- Locate the Relevant Section
Use line references (if provided) or key terms from the question to find the right part of the passage. Don't rely on memory, go back to the text. Strong readers re-read strategically.
- Scan for Signal Words
Look for explicit causal connectors: because, therefore, as a result, consequently, due to, since, thus. If you find them, the relationship is likely spelled out. If you don't find them, you're dealing with an implicit relationship, and you'll need to reason from context.
- State the Relationship in Your Own Words
Before you even look at the answer choices, articulate the cause-and-effect connection yourself. Say it simply: "[This] happened because [that]." Having your own answer first protects you from being swayed by attractive-sounding wrong answers.
- Evaluate Each Answer Against Your Paraphrase
Compare every answer choice to the relationship you stated in Step 4. Eliminate answers that reverse the causation, confuse correlation with causation, introduce irrelevant details, or overreach beyond what the passage supports.
Metacognitive Checkpoint
After you select your answer, pause and ask yourself these three quick self-check questions:
- Did I identify which element is the cause and which is the effect?
- Does the passage actually support this direction of causation, or am I assuming?
- Is this answer supported by the passage, or does it go beyond what the author states?
These three questions take only a few seconds, but they catch the most common errors students make.
Time Management Tip
Cause-and-effect questions reward precision, not speed. If you rush and skip Step 4 (forming your own answer first), you're far more likely to fall for a trap. Invest the extra 15–20 seconds to state the relationship in your own words. That small investment saves you from second-guessing later, and often makes the right answer immediately obvious.
Practice Cause-and-Effect Reasoning with SAT-Style Questions
Note: The passages below are original, SAT-style constructions for practice; any names or details are fictionalized.
Each question below includes a short, SAT-style passage. Read carefully, apply the five-step strategy, and check your reasoning against the explanations.
Question 1
Based on the passage, the researchers concluded that outdoor workers in equatorial regions face elevated melanoma risk primarily because
Question 2
The passage most strongly suggests that the drop in cholera cases occurred because
Question 3
The passage suggests that the change in Margot's narrative voice was most likely a result of
Question 4
Which statement best reflects the researchers' position on the relationship between sleep and anxiety?
Question 5
According to the text, the population declines among native fish species were ultimately caused by
Key Takeaways for Cause-and-Effect Reasoning
- Signal words are your first clue, not your only clue. Words like because, therefore, and as a result make cause-and-effect explicit, but some of the most important causal relationships on the SAT are implied through sequence and proximity. Ask yourself: Is the author connecting these two ideas, even without a signal word?
- Always confirm the direction of causation. One of the SAT's favorite tricks is reversing cause and effect. Before selecting your answer, check: Which came first in the text? Does A cause B, or does B cause A?
- Correlation is not causation. Two things happening at the same time or in sequence does not prove that one caused the other. When a passage presents a statistical association, look carefully for whether the author actually claims a causal link. Ask: Does the passage say one thing caused the other, or only that they occurred together?
- Form your own answer before reading the choices. This single habit is your strongest defense against every trap type. If you can state the causal relationship in your own words first, wrong answers lose most of their power to mislead you.
Conclusion: The Core Rule for Cause-and-Effect Reasoning
Cause-and-effect reasoning isn't just an SAT skill, it's a thinking skill that shows up every time you read a news article, evaluate a scientific claim, or try to understand why someone made a difficult decision. The strategy you practiced here, identifying the question type, returning to the text, scanning for signal words, forming your own answer, and evaluating choices with precision, works in all of those situations.
The more you practice tracing causal chains in passages, the more naturally it will come to you on test day. You won't need to consciously think through every step; the pattern recognition will start to happen automatically. That's the goal: not just to answer these questions correctly, but to become the kind of reader who instinctively asks why when reading anything.
Keep practicing with different passage types, science, history, literature, social science, and pay attention to the trap types you fall for most often. That awareness is what turns good practice into real improvement.
About the Instructor
